Would Roger Martin consider HRM to be a profession?

Would Roger Martin consider HRM to be a profession?
Human Resources

Would Roger Martin consider HRM to be a profession?To be frank, the academic literature on what makes a profession is not very accessible. Here is something of a different take on the topic. For some time, there has been an ongoing debate in the Harvard Business Review as to whether business management is, or should be, a profession. The debate started with an article written by Khurana, Nohria, and Penrice in 2005 entitled Is business management a profession?(1) A cogent rebuttal was published a few years later by Richard Barker in a 2010 article entitled The Big Idea: No, Management Is Not a Profession.(2) The debate drew commentary from many sources, one such commentary was by Roger Martin in an HBR Blog dated July 2010 entitled Management is not a profession — but it can be taught.(3) In this blog, Martin laid out his profession calculus:

So my basic calculus is as follows: If quality can’t be determined in advance and cost of failure is high, the market in question will attract regulation. And if the product/service is delivered by a single identifiable individual, it will become a regulated profession. If it doesn’t attract regulation, it doesn’t matter a whit whether an activity is deemed by its participants to be a ‘profession.’

It is this calculus and its application to Human Resources Management (HRM) which is the subject of this article.

Receive email updates
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

You May Also Like

ARTICLES

Human Resources
Talent Mobility: Reducing Self-imposed Barriers to Increase Mobility in Your Organization
Organizations need the right talent to succeed, and they need it now. Simply stated: I don’t think there is a CEO a...
Using a Facilitator for Negotiations
Labour Relations
Using a Facilitator for Negotiations
Is a facilitator a useful investment in labour negotiations? Can a facilitator assist with relationship building duri...
The Importance of a Trauma-Informed Approach to Workplace Investigations
Labour Relations
The Importance of a Trauma-Informed Approach to Workplace Investigations
Human Resources and Labour Relations professionals are typically not clinicians, physicians, or social workers. So wh...

PROGRAMS

Certificate in Organized Crime Prevention Foundations
Equip yourself with analytical skills, legal strategies, and cultural insights to mitigate criminal activity
A group of people sit against a large window with desks in front of them.
Workplace Restoration
Addressing a Toxic Workplace to Rebuild Relationships and Productivity.

Share this article

Page link
Copied!

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.