Internal Workplace Investigations: Considerations and Strategies

Having conducted both internal and external investigations throughout my career, it has been my experience that there are legitimate reasons why organizations may choose to conduct a workplace investigation internally as opposed to hiring an external professional investigator. However, to be effective, one must be conscious of the considerations unique to internal investigations, as well as inform oneself of and apply key strategies to overcome common concerns.

“Votre curriculum vitae, s’il vous plaît.”

The prerogative to use an internal investigator is implicitly granted in certain Ontario legislation such as the Occupational Health and Safety Act, which requires employers to conduct an investigation into workplace harassment “that is appropriate in the circumstances” but does not specify who the investigator, or what their qualifications, should be.[1] Even in extreme cases where a Ministry of Labour inspector orders an employer to conduct a workplace investigation, published guidance requires an “impartial person possessing such knowledge, experience, or qualification as are specified by the inspector”, noting that in some circumstances, this could conceivably be an internal employee, possibly from a corporate office, another franchise, etc.[2]

The requirement for investigative experience, qualifications, and training is also something sought by courts and human rights tribunals, however; there have been cases where they have gone further, criticizing workplace investigations where the investigator does not also have experience conducting investigations on subject matters relevant to the allegations at hand (e.g. sexual harassment).

The B-Word

However, as even the most experienced investigators understand well, no two investigations are identical, and each presents its own unique set of challenges. Some of these challenges are exacerbated by virtue of the investigation being conducted internally and thus having to overcome the ‘B-word’, considered deadly to most investigations. Through no fault of the assigned internal investigator, inherent actual and/or perceived bias looms over internal investigations like an ominous spectre given existing relationships and connections across the organization. Further, there are individuals and groups in orbit that may have a curious but unrequired interest in the progress and outcome of an investigation, such as other HR professionals, managers, labour relations departments, unions, etc., with whom the investigator may have a past and/or desired future working relationship (and who in fact may become involved in the aftermath of the investigation, such as for discipline, reassignment, etc.).

This is particularly relevant for a respondent employee who might have a less-than-spotless record, as the perilous introduction of similar-fact evidence can arise. Additionally, in serious cases where management decides on termination following an investigation, one must be wary of whether management was looking to get rid of this person prior to the investigation, and the investigation may now be the perfect excuse (regardless of the findings).

As daunting the concern of bias is, there yet exist other challenges and considerations unique to internal workplace investigations. To more easily frame these, we’ll discuss them next in the context of the commonly considered four fundamentals of workplace investigations, Timeliness, Thoroughness, Confidentiality, and Fairness.

Tick, Tock

Speaking to both the responsiveness with which an organization reacts to a complaint as well as the duration of time until the investigation is concluded, the fundamental of timeliness’ raison d’être is not only as a duty of care towards achieving distributive justice for a complainant (demonstrating the organization’s serious commitment to resolving complaints), but also as a practical matter to achieve procedural justice (since memory fades with time and so with it the details that could make all the difference in an investigator’s findings of fact).

From a trauma-informed perspective, an unresolved complaint can be an anxiety-provoking situation regardless of the employee’s role in the investigation and even if it has been determined from a physical and/or psychological safety perspective (medically or otherwise) that the employee can continue to work during its course despite the experiencing of awkwardness, discomfort, worry, etc.

However, notwithstanding the foregoing considerations, HR departments are often understaffed since they are frequently seen as a cost centre, with smaller organizations also having less specialization in the roles, meaning no dedicated full-time internal workplace investigators. As such, for many organizations, the individual conducting the workplace investigation is likely juggling other HR duties such as staff planning (e.g. recruitment and terminations), employee/labour relations matters (e.g. disciplines and grievances, collective bargaining), etc. With these “live” projects or day-to-day workloads, investigations into alleged misdeeds may be de-prioritized, causing this workplace investigation fundamental to suffer.

Leave No Stone Unturned (to a Balance of Probabilities)

If timeliness is one side of a coin, thoroughness is the other; one of the ingredients in the workplace investigation secret sauce is for the investigator to know how to strike an appropriate balance.

Regardless, however, of this need for equilibrium, one cannot understate the importance of collecting evidence – security access logs, e-mails, online chat histories, vacation reports, timecard records, cellphone bills, security camera footage, police reports, public records…. there may be several sources for documentary evidence that is corroborative and thus invaluable to a workplace investigation. The internal investigator may be at an advantage (versus an external investigator) due to familiarity with the systems and processes in place.

However, the internal investigator cannot rely upon what is historically known of the parties, for this is a common trap of bias. By way of example, one or more of the parties to the investigation may be in the process of being performance managed or have past performance issues, or perhaps the internal investigator had previously investigated one or both of the parties on separate matters; however, this does not mean that the complaint is not valid or should not be investigated, or that one should make assumptions about the direction the investigation may or should take.

When it comes to audio or video recording of interviews to improve the accuracy of analysis in the pursuit of thoroughness, this is something external investigators may do regularly. However, an internal workplace investigator often cannot make recordings due to internal policy or collective agreement stipulations. More recently available software can simultaneously record and transcribe an interview, however, even that has been prohibited by some collective agreements. Notwithstanding, taking accurate notes on the exact phrasing of responses by interviewees is vital, but can be exhausting when taken by hand and slow down the interview.

Loose Lips Sink Investigations

At the end of the day, even after repeatedly cautioning the parties/participants about the importance of confidentiality towards the integrity of the investigation, the likelihood is high that other employees know an investigation is happening as well as the identities of the parties. However, it is the investigator’s responsibility to ensure no leaks come from their side of the fence.

As an internal investigator, there may be an inclination to share progress reports with, and/or seek advice from, the HR supervisor. While potentially appropriate in the circumstances, the reality is the more people privy to the details of a workplace investigation, the more challenging it is to uphold the workplace investigation fundamental of confidentiality, notwithstanding everything “HR” is supposed to fall under the ‘cone of silence’. Further, given HR’s existing relationships as business consultants or advisors to other departmental people leaders, there may be pressure to provide updates or give certain information as “FYI” before the investigation concludes.

There is also the unintentional breach that can arise out of modern open-concept office layouts, keeping in mind that people (and not necessarily only HR staff) walk in and out of the office for many reasons and may overhear sensitive conversations or calls to request information. Technology has a role to play here as well; most organizations are set up on shared network drive/SharePoint-type systems, where restricted access to the investigation’s information to protect privacy (both during and post) has to be deliberately contemplated and implemented…but is it?

The investigator’s duty of confidentiality doesn’t end when the interviews are concluded. Common considerations include:

  • Once the report has been finalized, who are the results shared with, and to what level of detail?
  • If corrective measures are to be taken against the respondent, to what extent should the complainant be privy?
  • Do the parties owe a continued duty of confidentiality after the investigation is finalized?

My Fair Investigator

Most would agree that a workplace investigation must be conducted in a procedurally fair manner. But what does this look like in real life (outside of attempts to avoid bias), and why is it arguably the most important investigation fundamental?

Procedural fairness must be applied throughout the investigation process, but most of its part to play arises during the interview stage. Each party should be given notice of and introduction to the proceedings and have equal opportunity to be heard, to provide their evidence/witnesses, and to respond to information provided by others. From a trauma-informed perspective, all reasonable measures must be taken such that each party is made to feel safe, both physically and psychologically.

Whether intentionally or not, applying inconsistent processes or steps to carrying out investigations can be a faux pas on many levels when it comes to procedurally sound investigations. Inconsistencies, whether unintended or deliberate (potentially due to the nature of, or relationship with, the parties involved), can lead to claims of discrimination or unequal treatment. Just as the investigation may be a widely known secret, complaints about the investigation process being unfair will spread like wildfire; after all, doesn’t bad news tend to travel faster than good news?

The reputation and credibility of HR are always on the line with internal investigations, and how HR is viewed by the populace can affect future investigations, whether by way of under-reporting of complaints, or degree of participation if called as a participant. If enough balls are dropped and there is a failure to achieve a consistent perception of procedural fairness, it chips away at organizational trust (i.e. the faith that employees have in management and the organization to do the right thing). Employee engagement is then placed at risk, with knock-on effects to departmental and organizational performance. This is why it could be suggested that fairness be seen as the most important of the workplace investigation fundamentals. The same argument can be made for distributive justice; when there is a power differential between the complainant and respondent (e.g. if one is an executive), investigation steps may be (inappropriately) curtailed or sidestepped in order for that executive to save face, resulting in a different investigation outcome than would have otherwise occurred.

As a unique challenge to internal investigators, they may have to follow through on their own recommendations, whether disciplinary or otherwise, as part of their regular HR duties in support of that internal client group.  While not ideal from a desired impartiality perspective (particularly as the investigator may have to work with the parties or witnesses or their respective union representatives on future matters), this is the practical reality, particularly in smaller organizations.

Tips and Strategies

None of these measures are trade secrets. The key to success is to have a strong and consistent handle on the workplace investigation fundamentals.

  • Banish the bias. Make all efforts to recognize and avoid investigator or procedural bias, conscious or unconscious, actual or perceived.
    • The inherent or perceived bias colours who should (or should not) take on the investigation.
    • Eschew the organization’s pre-existing perception of the relationship between employer and employee (whether favourable or not).
    • Stick to the facts and do not take shortcuts (potentially based on misconceptions) at the cost of being thorough.
    • Ensure all parties have a fair and equal opportunity to be heard.
  • Be responsive. Have a set complaint intake procedure and meet with the parties/participants as close as possible to when the complaint arose.
    • Promptly conduct an initial assessment of the allegations (e.g. threshold test, and initial screening for potential investigator biases), and identification of potentially necessary input from other departments (e.g. occupational health).
    • Seize the opportunity for the parties/participants to access memory recall as best as possible.
    • Provide less time for potential tampering with witnesses (notwithstanding all parties/participants are formally advised about the importance of confidentiality and non-contact with other parties/participants in the investigation).
    • Demonstrate the organization’s commitment to addressing complaints in a timely manner.
  • Document, document, document. Details are critical to an investigation, and sometimes you don’t know which are the critical ones until later.
    • Have basics such as well-formatted, user-friendly, detailed complaint intake forms as well as organized systems for cataloguing documentary evidence submissions and cross-referencing them against allegations and incidents.
    • Standardized internal investigation forms can help ensure consistency across investigations and provide tension for timeliness by providing suggested deadlines for completion of each investigation stage. For example, through a series of fixed steps in the form (including mandatory managerial sign-off as considered appropriate), one could record the summary of complaints, identify whether any Human Rights Code violations are alleged, decide if early alternative dispute resolution is appropriate, detail the evidence collected, record key statements by the parties, summarize the various findings of fact, attest to the parties being individually notified of the results, etc. In more straightforward cases, this completed form could supplant a requirement for a full report.
    • For more complex investigations (provided internal resources are available), consider co-investigators to jointly conduct interviews – having two sets of notes may result in a more fulsome and accurate aggregate set of recorded details. Moreover, if the co-investigators are from different HR departments/groups (i.e. viewed as neutral relative to the parties involved), this may help deflect concerns of bias.
    • Retention of notes, evidence, and the report (if any) is also essential in the post-investigation world, not only for institutional memory reasons as staff move around/leave the organization, but also as documentation for disciplinary and possibly litigious purposes down the road. That said, investigation files are to be kept separate from personnel files (other than potentially a record of discipline).
  • Proactively protect privacy. Maintaining confidentiality is paramount to preserving people’s reputation and integrity, especially since rumours can potentially harm their ability to apply for internal job or training opportunities, succession planning, bonuses, etc.
    • If an employee involved in an investigation must be removed from the workplace for safety concerns, prepare the management team on how to respond neutrally to questions on the employee’s whereabouts.
    • Investigative calls should be conducted in an enclosed office whenever possible.
    • Take caution when discussing workload internally with coworkers or at team meetings – confidentiality still needs to be maintained irrespective of the false comfort of a team setting.
    • Computerized folders should have restricted access permissions on a need-to-know basis (principle of least privilege) and files password-protected. Paper files (if any) should be under lock and key with supervised access.
    • Consider having an anonymous complaint procedure and/or a whistleblower hotline; these would be considered ‘institutional’ investigations. While more susceptible to bad faith complaints, it is better that the organization provide complainants who have legitimate fears of retaliation with avenues of redress rather than risk the underreporting of incidents.
  • Use a trauma-informed approach, universally. At a high level, this means conducting the investigation with compassion, flexibility, and without judgment, and taking this approach consistently with all parties and witnesses to an investigation, in the spirit of procedural fairness.
    • Ensure the interviewee is aware of support options (e.g. union representation, programs available through employee benefits, etc.), particularly if they have witnessed a horrific or gruesome event.
    • Schedule interviews when convenient for the interviewee, and if in person, arrange them in well-lit, comfortable, unlocked yet private locations (i.e. not the typical departmental boardroom).
    • Phrase questions in a way that would not cause the interviewee to have a defensive reaction and give choice in the order of questions and/or how the party wants to proceed in giving their side of the story.

The Wrap Up

As you may have gathered by now, the top consideration when conducting internal investigations is the inherent bias (whether actual or perceived) which can creep into every facet of the process and potentially undermine the outcome.

By thoughtfully establishing structure around the investigative process, consistently applying best practices as to how investigations are conducted, and taking proactive steps to mitigate procedural or investigator bias, the organization can display a robust process that inspires perceptions of distributive and procedural justice, thus enhancing organizational trust and realizing its beneficial outcomes.

About the Author

Tova Bar-Dayan

Tova Bar-Dayan, MIR, CHRL, WFA, is an independent HR/LR consultant and workplace investigator with progressive roles in both public and private sectors, in unionized and non-unionized environments. She takes great pride in conducting workplace investigations, assessments and restorations that are thorough, impartial, trauma-informed and, above all else, put people first. During her time in corporate roles as well as with her consulting firm, Tova has investigated claims of harassment, sexual harassment, workplace bullying, racism/anti-black racism, theft, improper conduct, and more, including those which could have resulted in significant litigation and/or reputational risk. This experience is bolstered by her status as a licensed private investigator (Ontario).

 

[1] Government of Ontario. (n.d.). Part III.0.I: Workplace violence and workplace harassment: Guide to the Occupational Health and Safety Act. Retrieved from https://www.ontario.ca/document/guide-occupational-health-and-safety-act/part-iii0i-workplace-violence-and-workplace-harassment

[2] Government of Ontario. (n.d.-a). Code of practice to address workplace harassment. Retrieved from https://www.ontario.ca/page/code-practice-address-workplace-harassment

 

Download a PDF of the full article above: Internal Workplace Investigations: Considerations and Strategies

The Importance of a Trauma-Informed Approach to Workplace Investigations

Human Resources and Labour Relations professionals are typically not clinicians, physicians, or social workers. So why has the vast and complicated area of “trauma”, more commonly relevant for those in medical or emergency services, become so crucial for us to understand? And more than that, what does being “trauma-informed” mean and how does it relate to workplace investigations?

To answer these questions, we must first begin with our raison d’être as a workplace investigator – that of being a fact-finder.  Employing procedural fairness, our job is to piece together a workplace incident based on multiple perspectives and determine if wrongdoing has transpired. By interviewing all parties involved, we seek detailed information and assess credibility. We use our people skills to build rapport, we practice active listening and we avoid making assumptions about the outcome. How we conduct ourselves with all parties to an investigation has a direct impact on the quality of the information received (i.e., finding all the facts). This, in turn, affects the accuracy of the investigation’s outcome and the suitability of follow-up recommendations. Moreover, a well (or poorly) conducted investigation can have an impact on organizational trust (i.e., the employees’ trust in supervisors and the organization), which can lead to favourable (or detrimental) influence on overall organizational performance.

The Centre for Addiction and Mental Health (CAMH) defines trauma as “…the lasting emotional response that often results from living through a distressing event.” One such context that is an exception to this rule is generational trauma, whereby a group of people with shared characteristics experiences trauma from systemic abuse, discrimination/racism, war, etc., and subsequent generations experience indirect suffering from those events.

CAMH continues to state that “Experiencing a traumatic event can harm a person’s sense of safety, sense of self, and ability to regulate emotions and navigate relationships. Long after the traumatic event occurs, people with trauma can often feel shame, helplessness, powerlessness and intense fear.” From this, we surmise that trauma can have long-lasting and wide-ranging adverse impacts on the individual beyond the immediate aftermath of a traumatic incident. It would then be fair to expect that such trauma is not left at home when employees come to the workplace.

Further, trauma need not only occur in employees’ personal lives but can also arise in the workplace itself, e.g. sexual assault, workplace violence or bullying, or even major organizational decisions such as job cuts or reassignments that may significantly impact employees’ lives. We must also be cognizant that in todays, and likely future, paradigm of remote work, this means an employee could experience a workplace trauma even from their home office.

Returning to trauma’s relevance vis-à-vis workplace investigations and our pursuit of the truth, we must recognize that one of our brain’s primary functions is to protect us from danger. In the aftermath of a traumatic event, neurological changes can occur in the brain (the housing unit for information) that impact how one remembers the traumatic event. These events can impact our authority over memory (i.e., the capacity to recall a trauma experience as a cohesive narrative), perception, and the ability to recount details of events.

By asking questions, we effectively ask – can you please enter your conventional memory storage unit and retrieve this piece of information? We know though for some, the impact of trauma may have altered the location of the memory housing unit and thus, the conventional (i.e., chronological) line of questioning may not be the best path to seek answers. Asking “what else happened?” may be better than “what happened next?”

Additionally, traumatic impact may cause a range of emotions that can influence the information sought, as emotional experiences/distresses can have significant impact on an individual’s response (or lack thereof) in the context of investigations. For example, an interviewee’s fear, shame, or anger may lead to outbursts which can derail an interview, curtail the individual’s cooperation, and prevent obtaining all the necessary and pertinent facts.

Because individuals respond differently to trauma, an investigator must be equipped to handle the process accordingly. However, the training, knowledge base, and skill set required to be trauma-informed does not mean we are now taking on the role of a psychologist (or the like) in carrying out a workplace investigation. A trauma-informed approach is an enhanced version of the skills and techniques we already employ as an investigator, and can be applied to widely-accepted successful interviewing approaches such as the PEACE method. It means first recognizing trauma, then understanding how, what, where, and when to ask questions, and then employing techniques and strategies that support a process for mitigating or reducing the possibility of re-traumatization.

Trauma-informed training offers skills and tools to help interviewees feel present, grounded, refocused, and safe. For example, it can help investigators de-escalate a flashback reaction, or keep an open mind when interpreting what some will find to be difficult behaviours like depression, anxiety, irritability, impatience, agitation, or anger. Even a panic attack can be misinterpreted, and possibly interpreted as a manifestation of guilt. It is important to recognize that an individual’s mastery of trauma-induced symptoms do not necessarily reflect a lack of credibility, such as a lack of eye contact, slumping posture, and/or reddening of the face and neck – all traditionally associated with shame and guilt.

If a trauma-informed approach is not employed correctly or at all, detrimental effects could include re-traumatizing the interviewee, which may result in an already distressed party going off on (longer) medical leave, or a lengthier investigation. Consequences could also include incomplete information and possibly insufficiently supported (or worse, erroneous) investigation outcomes. Further, if the investigation is perceived by employees as having been improperly conducted, there could be broader implications as organizational trust and reputation may suffer, and indirectly, so too could organizational performance.

However, by correctly employing a trauma-informed approach such that the interviewee feels safe in the interview, including exercising empathy, establishing rapport, and building trust, as well as giving the interviewee a sense of control (e.g. choice of returning to unanswered or difficult questions later in the interview), it should be expected that the interviewee will likely be more forthcoming with information and even willing to participate in a follow-up interview if necessary. Having obtained all pertinent information due to the “informed” approach, yielding the correct investigational outcome results in employees’ being more trusting of the investigation process, contributing towards organizational trust.  With improved organizational trust, a culture of underreporting incidents might be positively shifted as employees gain faith that procedural fairness will consistently transpire and justice will be done.

To summarize, workplace investigators don’t need to be experts in neuro-psychology, they just have to have a basic level of trauma-informed training. This will help them create an environment of safety, remain neutral, and validate the psychological struggles interviewees may experience during an interview.  As the saying goes, “one does not have to be a therapist to be therapeutic.”

Tips for Trauma-Informed Interviews

  • Ensure the interview is conducted in a safe, private place and in an unhurried manner
  • Exercise empathy, but do not say “I understand” or “I know how you feel”; use neutral language
  • Plan your questions but be flexible – do not lead with the hardest questions first
  • Maintain open-ended and non-suggestive questions
  • Afford interviewees a sense of control by potentially returning to unanswered questions later, or seeking their permission before showing graphical evidence
  • Minimize interruptions
  • Permit a support person in the interview (though set guidelines as to the degree of their involvement)

Benefits of a Trauma-Informed Approach

  • Avoid re-traumatization
  • Higher yield of information
  • More accurate investigation findings
  • Indirect enhancement of organizational trust
  • Reduce potential underreporting of incidents

About the Author

Tova Bar-Dayan

Tova Bar-Dayan, MIR, CHRL, WFA, is an independent HR/LR consultant and workplace investigator with progressive roles in both public and private sectors, in unionized and non-unionized environments. She takes great pride in conducting workplace investigations, assessments and restorations that are thorough, impartial, trauma-informed and, above all else, put people first. During her time in corporate roles as well as with her consulting firm, Tova has investigated claims of harassment, sexual harassment, workplace bullying, racism/anti-black racism, theft, improper conduct, and more, including those which could have resulted in significant litigation and/or reputational risk. This experience is bolstered by her status as a licensed private investigator (Ontario).

 

Download a PDF of the full article above: The Importance of a Trauma-Informed Approach to Workplace Investigations

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.